05/08/2021
Amazing resource! Want to know what's happened in St Helena's Historic Elm Tunnel since the historic 2011 agreement to both preserve and restore this landmark? And what does the future hold? Here is the 186-page(!) report from the horticultural consultants as presented to the City Council in January 2021.
Background and vision statement excepted below. The whole plan is on the City of St. Helena website.
https://sthelena.civicweb.net/document/47870/Annual%20Elm%20Tree%20Tunnel%20Update%20and%20Presentation%20.pdf?handle=277C01E75F37473897F68FE8DDC4DAB3
Beringer Elm Tunnel Management Plan HortScience | Bartlett Consulting, Nov 2020, presented to City Council January 2021.
BACKGROUND
In 1885 Beringer Brothers planted an alee of American elms (Ulmus Americana) in front of their winery, located just north of downtown St. Helena. The two rows of elms now create a tunnel of canopy over Highway 29, known as the St. Helena Historic Elm Tunnel (the Elm Tunnel). The Beringer Vineyards and Winery and local community want to perpetuate the Elm Tunnel experience for the community and visitors. The trees are recognized components of the Beringer Winery Historic District, and contribute to the National Historic Landmarks Program designation of the site.
At approximately 135 years of age, the original elms are reaching the end of their normal expected lifespan. Over the years, individual trees in the stand have died due to Dutch elm
disease (DED), creating gaps in the canopy. Some trees have failed, losing branches that fell onto the highway. Young elms include three generations of replacement trees planted by the City between 2011 and 2019.
The trees are growing on California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) property and located within the City of St. Helena. Maintenance responsibilities for pruning, disease management, tree removal and planting of new trees are shared by the State and City. This unique dynamic requires a partnership between the vested parties to develop and implement a strategic plan for preserving the functional and aesthetic beauty of the trees into the future.
The City of St. Helena requested that HortScience | Bartlett Consulting, Divisions of The F. A. Bartlett Tree Expert Company (H|BC) visually inspect the trees and prepare a Tree Risk
Assessment Report that described the risk associated with each tree and recommends risk abatement treatments. That report was completed in Nov. 2019 and included 144 trees, 88 of
which were mature and 56 of which were young. Based on the results of the 2019 risk assessment, we performed advanced inspections, including aerial and/or internal decay inspections of 27 trees and revised our management recommendations as appropriate based on those results, which were provided in the Updated Risk Assessment (Oct. 8, 2020).
Perpetuating the experience and benefits of the elm tunnel into the future requires thoughtful, strategic tree management that includes removal of old, dying trees and planting new ones to
replace them. To help guide management decisions, the City of St. Helena asked H|BC to prepare an Elm Tree Management Plan (ETMP). The purpose of the ETMP is to identify the goals, actions and priorities for tree management from ‘cradle to grave’ for the next 15 years. This document is a result of that effort.
A VISION FOR THE ELM TUNNEL
Through conversations with City staff, review of relevant documents, and comprehensive evaluation of the tree resource, H|BC developed a vision statement and near term and long term
goals to meet that vision.
VISION STATEMENT
The historic aesthetic, functional and experiential features of the elm tunnel that contribute to the Historic Landmark designation of the Beringer winery are sustained into the future for the benefit of the St. Helena community and visitors.
GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
The Elm Tunnel will be sustained into the future through adaptive management to foster tree health and structural stability, and by selective removal and replacement of declining and hazardous trees with DED resistant American elm tree varieties.
1. Sustain the integrity of the Elm Tunnel for future generations to experience.
a. Plan for the removal and replacement of individual trees as they reach the end of their lifespan.
b. Protect trees from injury by vehicles and avoidable wounding by maintenance activities.
2. Manage the trees to minimize risk of damage to people and property while preserving historic trees within the limits of their lifespan.
a. Identify, remove and replace highest-risk trees.
b. Visually Inspect trees annually and following storms to identify structural weaknesses and provide appropriate abatement treatments.
3. Foster tree health and structural stability to prolong life of individual trees to the
extent possible.
a. Identify reliable source(s) of DED-resistant replacement elms.
b. Purchase high quality, pest free trees.
c. Prepare planting sites and install new trees according to best management practices and industry standards.
d. Provide good quality irrigation water according to tree needs.
e. Prune young trees annually for first 5 to 10 years to develop strong structure that minimizes branch failure and need for large pruning cuts on mature trees.
f. Monitor trees for signs and symptoms of DED and other pests.
g. Provide adaptive management that responds to changes in pest pressure, environment, weather extremes, and tree age.
4. Engage with the community.
a. Engage with the St. Helena’s Elm Tunnel Army, the St. Helena Beautification Foundation and St. Helena’s Historic Elm Tunnel page.
b. Consider opportunities for the community to be involved in caring for the Elm Tunnel, such as elm tree planting events.
c. Consider creating a page on the City’s website about the Elm Tunnel plan and activities.
d. Consider providing open access to historic and current information about individual trees in the Elm Tunnel (similar to New York City).
e. Consider creating birth certificates for new trees and maintaining growth charts.
f. Consider allowing the public to send love letters to trees (similar to Melbourne).
g. Consider ways to utilize wood from removed trees in community projects, art installations and educational installations.