04/01/2026
STRONG HEART by Charlie Sheldon is this month’s book.
Tom is preparing to go on a camping trip in Olympic National Park with his indigenous friends William and Myra. While they’re packing, his ex-wife shows up with a granddaughter Tom never knew existed. (His ex-wife had custody of their daughter, who ran away from home at 15.) The granddaughter, Sarah, acts like a stereotypical sullen teenager who does NOT want to go on this trip, but, after some debate among the original campers, Tom decides to take her. He’s going to tend his grandfather’s grave, and it’s important.
At the park, they encounter surveyors for Buckhorn, a mining company that has mineral rights to the area where Tom’s grandfather is buried. Once they’re deeper in the wilderness, Tom shows his friends a carved atlatl that his grandfather had given him, which he wants to leave at the grave. Tom isn’t sure if his grandfather found this himself, or if his own grandfather had given it to him, and he isn’t sure exactly where it came from. The surveyors pass by their camp, and they may have seen the atlatl. If so, the group knows they’ll want to suppress any knowledge of it in case the existence of an archaeological site would derail their mining plans. Sarah, who is an artist, sees a bear in the woods, but when she shows the group her drawing of the bear Myra identifies it as a short-faced bear, which has been extinct since the ice age.
Then Sarah disappears and is missing for a week. Tom et al. refuse to stop searching even after official search and rescue efforts end, though he doesn’t really expect to find her alive. And then she reappears during a thunderstorm, injured in several ways, including missing part of her little finger. She relates an amazing story: while she was gone, she woke up on a shore somewhere and was captured, along with six other similar-aged girls. Their captors took them to trade for obsidian (“razor stone”) with a group who periodically came to trade for wives. Sarah, soon called Strong Heart by her new people, traveled by giant canoe (something like those used among Northwest Coast peoples in recent centuries) for months. Along the way she learned to throw with an atlatl and became quite proficient. Unfortunately the travelers suffered a series of misfortunes, both from predators and from each other jockeying for position. Just as they were about to arrive at their home, Sarah returned to the modern world, led by a short-faced bear.
Back in the present day, Tom and Myra are skeptical of Sarah’s story (William is more inclined to take things like visions seriously), but they focus on healing her injuries and getting things back to normal. Sarah has to return to her grandmother’s house, but a few months later she runs away to get away from her step-grandfather, and the gang returns to the wilderness to try to retrieve the atlatl (lost during the first adventure). But the Buckhorn employees are back too, and they won’t let an artifact stand in the way of their plans…
The story is intriguing and keeps you engaged. It would have been nice to get a little more into the heads of the main characters. It feels like there’s always some distance between the reader and the viewpoint character. It’s also disappointing that Sarah leaves the past just as they’re reaching her new people’s home. It would have been interesting to see how they lived when they weren’t traveling.
The author seems to have written this book partly to advance the coastal migration hypothesis (that humans moved along the coast from Siberia into North America rather than entering the Americas through an ice-free corridor from Beringia). Sarah’s journey, the group decides, probably started in Kamchatka and ended up in Washington state. In an afterword the author talks about having thought about this idea for decades (he worked in the Pacific Northwest with tribes and with sea-related matters). By this point in time, this idea is fairly well accepted by archaeologists. The public awareness of ideas often lags behind the archaeological community, but fiction is an effective way of getting ideas out there (for good or ill, depending on whether the ideas are serious science or crackpot pseudoarchaeology). The author also clearly knows what he’s talking about when it comes to sailing in the northern Pacific and traveling through the forest.
There are a few strange ideas, mainly that the Pacific Northwest was where modern humanity began. The characters talk about early humans mixing with Neandertals and Denisovans (and some of Strong Heart’s fellow captives seem to be coded as Neandertals, described as having heavy bones and red hair). This lets William and Myra be right that their ancestors came from the same place they still live and their people have always been there, but it’s a muddled version of the real data. Modern humans did interbreed with Neandertals and Denisovans, but not, as far as we know, all together in the greater Beringia region. In fact, to date no Neandertal remains have been found that far east. This is a minor point in the book, though.
There are other fictional depictions of populating the Americas, but not like this one. It’s worth a look.