05/05/2026
Nadia I. Shihata, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Investigation (DOI), issued a Report today on the obstacles to DOI’s independent oversight of the City’s child welfare system due to the New York State Social Services Law (SSL) and the discretion provided by certain provisions of the SSL to a state entity. Specifically, five provisions in the law significantly restrict DOI’s access to records of the City Administration for Children’s Services (ACS) that are essential for rigorous oversight that includes investigating systemic or policy failures, criminality, corruption, and inefficiencies. This Report seeks to bring the public’s attention to the impediments presented by State law and the interpretation of these laws by state regulators that consistently hinder DOI investigations and the fulfillment of DOI’s legal mandate. Legislation has already been introduced into the state legislature by Senator Jabari Brisport and Assemblymember Andrew Hevesi that would allow DOI to fulfill its City Charter-mandated duty to oversee ACS’s performance and help ensure that ACS programs protect the City’s children.
Read the report here: https://bit.ly/4wqQI3E
DOI Commissioner Nadia I. Shihata said, “DOI wholeheartedly supports the pending state legislation because it provides access to critical records that are essential for DOI to conduct rigorous and independent oversight that helps ensure ACS’s programs are effectively safeguarding the children in this City. Without this access, DOI cannot obtain the full picture of ACS’s actions. DOI’s comprehensive investigations have a meaningful impact by upholding best practices as well as providing accountability when there is criminality or other misconduct. Just as important, DOI’s investigations, including in ACS-related matters, support the many City workers who do their jobs everyday with integrity and instill public confidence in City operations.”
This Report was prepared by Deputy Inspector General Harlyn Griffenberg and Senior Inspector General Laura Millendorf of DOI’s Office of the Inspector General for ACS, assisted by Director of Intergovernmental Affairs/Special Counsel Rebecca Chasan and Special Investigative Counsel Zachary Bannon, and was supervised by Acting Deputy Commissioner/Chief of Investigations Audrey Feldman and Deputy Commissioner of Strategic Initiatives Christopher Ryan.