01/23/2025
After careful thought and reflection, I have decided to let this page go quiet for now. I cannot support a total ban that takes women's lives, and that HAS ALREADY HAPPENED and WILL HAPPEN AGAIN. There's nothing Pro-Life about women being forced to carry dead babies, have miscarriage treatment withheld, or being put in medically precarious positions while we tie doctors' hands.
The Court went too far, and some states are being draconian in their interpretations. Pre-Roe, there were always situations like this that were left to medical discretion. Would that we'd gotten a ruling that allowed for that, or a 9-week ban, or even 15-weeks under certain conditions, as many countries have. Abortion rates have gone up since Dobbs was decided. So much for making abortion rare.
This total ban was not what many Whole-Life Democrats and Progressives were driving at. We're back at a place where women's lives are at risk, and policies that are pulling support for women with children---cutting school lunches, diverting money from public schools, etc.---is being rammed down Tennesseans' throats by the GOP Super-Majority.
That should be common ground for ALL Tennessee Democrats and those who wanted a return to safe, legal (at doctor's discretion), and rare; also common ground of creating and implementing policy that supports women who find themselves in a crisis or unplanned pregnancy.
We should be standing up for HEAD START, WIC, SNAP, public schools, Pell Grants, and the Summer Lunch program that Lee wants to ax. How can we expect women to choose to bear and raise a child, but offer no help once that courageous and daunting decision is made? If Pro-Life Democrats' positions are indistinguishable from Republican ones, why bother to call ourselves Democrats?
We need a more nuanced positioning that acknowledges that sometimes a woman needs a D & C to save her life, and robust support for women who choose to bear a child. Do I sound frustrated?
I AM frustrated. Dobbs has borne strange fruit we were warned about, and that rigidity has cost women their lives, alongside sometimes VERY much wanted children they wanted to bear and raise and love. I'm not suddenly Pro-Choice or for abortion-on-demand, but if "Pro-Life" policies are killing women, I'm not for that, either.
As Democrats, the party, writ-large, insisted on no restrictions, rather than the kinds of compromises many countries have. That extreme helped get us here. I can't celebrate a victory with Dobbs, because it hasn't gotten it right, either.
As a woman whose Pro-Life doctor refused to perform a needed D & C to remove her deceased 10-week of gestation baby, I am troubled that in many places, this is the law of the land, not just a doctor's whim. It was traumatic enough that I never carried a child again, and we adopted, instead.
Women deserved better than Roe. Now it is clear that Dobbs is killing and maiming some women. This isn't what I signed up for as a Pro-Life Feminist and Democrat.
For the foreseeable future, this page is going dark. I don't want to be seen as being on the side of the people who don't care about the unintended consequences of Dobbs and silent on Republican positions that will punish the poor and at-risk children born, but otherwise not provided for or supported.
Is that really what we've wrought by mirroring GOP strictures on abortion? I hope not, but am very afraid we did. That means blood on our hands, and I'm not okay with that. I never have been.