What are the opening hours?

Monday 8am - 4pm Tuesday 8am - 4pm Wednesday 8am - 4pm Thursday 8am - 4pm Friday 8am - 4pm

Jefferson County Prosecutor David Sutter

Home
United States
Madison, IN
Jefferson County Prosecutor David Sutter

The Official page for the Jefferson County Prosecutor's Office. This account is not meant to provide a public forum.

PAGE POSTING GUIDELINES:

In order to better serve and communicate with the public, the Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney maintains an account through this third-party social media platform. While the views and comments of the public are welcome, this site is monitored and comments may be deleted to ensure compliance with the Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct. Submitting personally identi

fiable information (PII) is not required to interact with or access information from the Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney through this platform. To protect your privacy and the privacy of others, please do not include phone numbers, email addresses, social security numbers, case numbers, or any other sensitive PII in your comments or responses. If you have specific questions regarding a Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney activity or program that involves details you do not wish to share publicly, please contact the office at (812) 265-8932. Defendants charged in a criminal case face a mere accusation of guilt and they are presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty. For this reason and others, prosecuting attorneys are not permitted to discuss certain aspects of their cases. For example, they cannot make statements that “have a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing an adjudicative proceeding.” They cannot make statements regarding “the character, credibility, reputation or criminal record of a party, suspect in a criminal investigation or witness, or the identity of a witness, or the expected testimony of a party or witness.” Statements that a prosecuting attorney cannot make will be deleted from the website even when made by a member of the public and not the prosecuting attorney or staff. For more information see Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct 3.6 and 3.8(f) which are available here: https://www.in.gov/judiciary/rules/prof_conduct/index.html . The Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney also reserves the discretion to hide, delete or not allow comments that contain:

• Vulgar or abusive language;
• Personal or obscene attacks of any kind;
• Offensive terms targeting individuals or groups;
• Threats or defamatory statements;
• Links to any site;
• Suggestions or encouragement of illegal activity;
• Multiple successive off-topic posts by a single user or repetitive posts copied and pasted by multiple users, or spam;
• Unsolicited proposals or other business ideas or inquiries;
• Promotion or endorsement of commercial services, products, or entities; or
• Personally identifiable information that has been inappropriately posted. Activity on a third-party social media platforms is governed by the security and privacy policies of the third-party. Please note: certain information associated with your account may be made available to us based on the privacy policies of the third-party and your privacy settings within that website. Each third-party platform may have unique features or practices. Individuals may wish to review the privacy policies of this platform before using it in order to understand how the information made available on this platform will be used. Individuals may also wish to adjust privacy settings on their accounts. The Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney encourages members of the public to offer comments as they relate to the topics being discussed. The views expressed in the comments reflect only those of the comment’s author, and do not necessarily reflect the official views of the Jefferson County Prosecuting Attorney. All comments, to include those removed from this platform, (including username and any identifying information provided) become publicly available, both at the time of posting and later, pursuant to Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act. Under the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act of 1998, persons under the age of 13 years old are not allowed to submit questions or comments.

05/14/2026

Tomorrow, May 15th is the LAST day to drop off donations for our Safe Passage Shelter Donation Drive! 📦💜

These donations provide more than just basic necessities. They provide comfort, stability, and hope for domestic violence survivors and their families during some of the hardest moments of their lives. Every item donated helps support individuals rebuilding their lives and reminds them that their community stands beside them.

Let’s come together and make one last big push. The Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office (315 1/2 E Second St., Madison, IN) will be open and accepting donations until 4pm tomorrow (May 15th).

Thank you to all who have and continue to donate during our drive. We’ve been so incredibly grateful for the generosity and support received from our community.

05/11/2026

We have been blown away by the outpouring generosity and support our community has shown throughout this donation drive for the Safe Passage Shelter.

As we head into the final days before the drive ends this Friday (May 15), we’re asking for one last push to help us finish strong. Every donation helps provide essential items for survivors and families, from toiletries and cleaning supplies to pantry staples and snacks.

Donations can be dropped off at the Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office through Friday, May 15, between 8AM–4PM.

Thank you to everyone who has donated, shared our posts, and helped support Safe Passage Shelter. Your kindness is making a real difference. 💜

05/10/2026

To all the moms and mother figures in our community and everywhere - thank you for the love, sacrifice, and strength you show every day.

We hope your Mother’s Day is filled with appreciation and time with those you love most!

05/08/2026

SHANE BOTTOMS SENTENCED TO 13 YEARS FOR CHILD R**E

Shane Bottoms, 41, of Madison, Indiana was sentenced on May 8, 2026, in Jefferson Circuit Court by Judge D.J. Mote following his conviction on the lead charge of R**e, a Level Three (3) Felony.

In late 2025, Bottoms was incarcerated in the Jefferson County jail for a probation violation for an unrelated criminal matter, when a disclosure was made by the victim to a therapist regarding s*xual offenses committed by Bottoms prior to his incarceration.

The evidence and testimony gathered through the investigation, including a forensic interview conducted at the Children’s Advocacy Center of Southeastern Indiana, revealed that Bottoms repeatedly engaged in s*xual acts with the juvenile victim, who was residing in the same household as Bottoms. The investigation further established that Bottoms provided alcohol to the minor on multiple occasions, including prior to the charged assault.

“Shane Bottoms exploited a child and violated the trust and safety every young person deserves within their own home.” said Prosecutor David Sutter.

The investigation was led by Detective Ryan Harrison of the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office. During an interview conducted by Detective Harrison, Bottoms attempted to minimize the allegations and claimed the juvenile victim initiated the s*xual conduct toward him.

“The courage of the victim in coming forward, combined with the diligent investigative work conducted by Detective Harrison, allowed our office to secure accountability in this case” said Prosecutor Sutter.

Bottoms was sentenced by Judge D. J Mote to thirteen (13) years, with ten (10) of those years executed at the Department of Corrections. Bottoms was also determined to be a Serious Violent Felon and a S*xually Violent Predator requiring him to register as a S*x Offender for life.

During sentencing, Judge Mote addressed Bottoms saying “I hope that you understand the impact your actions have had on this child. It was a violation of trust. She will be struggling with this for the rest of her life and you should reflect on that during your time.”

Prosecutor Sutter thanked the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Department, Detective Ryan Harrison, the City of Madison Police Department, the Children’s Advocacy Center of Southeastern Indiana, the Department of Child Services, and CASA of Jefferson County (Court Appointed Special Advocates) for their dedicated efforts in pursuing safety and justice for the victim, which led to this conviction.

04/30/2026

The Jefferson County Prosecutor’s office is collecting donations to support the Safe Passage Shelter 💜

The Safe Passage Domestic Violence Shelter provides safety, support, and hope to individuals and families. Safe Passage has supported countless survivors in Jefferson County, and now they need our community’s support.

We’re collecting donations to help stock their pantry and provide essential everyday items for those utilizing the shelter. Every item given makes a real difference.

📦 Drop-off: Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office ( 315 1/2 E 2nd St., Madison, IN)
🕗 8 AM – 4 PM
📅 Donations accepted through May 15

Please check out the flyer for a full list of needed items and consider donating if you’re able.

Together, we can help ensure survivors have the resources, comfort, and care they deserve.

04/16/2026

STATE POLICE INVESTIGATION LEADS TO 29 DRUG RELATED ARRESTS

Jefferson County, Indiana (April 16, 2026) – A months-long investigation has led to 29 drug related arrests involving a distribution network of methamphetamine, co***ne, hydrocodone, and alprazolam pills. The Indiana State Police (ISP) led the Investigation, titled “Operation Clocked Out”.

“This operation reflects the culmination of extensive investigative work led by the Indiana State Police, strengthened through close coordination with multiple law enforcement agencies, whose combined efforts work to hold offenders accountable and enhance public safety.” said Prosecutor David Sutter.

Sutter also expressed appreciation for the support provided by the City of Madison Police Department and the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office during the ex*****on of the warrants. “Their assistance was instrumental to the success of this operation and reflects the strong interagency collaboration we rely on to protect our community,” Sutter said.

The investigation began in February of 2025, after learning that William “Flav” Taylor was a major supplier of methamphetamine in Jefferson County. Throughout the investigation, Officers were able to confirm that Taylor was sourcing his methamphetamine and co***ne from Louisville, Kentucky and Cincinnati, Ohio.

On February 4, 2026, Taylor was arrested on a warrant on one (1) Count of Dealing in Methamphetamine as a Level 2 Felony. Officers executed the arrest warrant of Taylor when he was travelling back to Jefferson County, Indiana from Louisville, KY. Taylor was also found to be in possession of Co***ne and received additional charges. Taylor is being held on a $500,000 full cash only bond in Jefferson County. Additional charges against Taylor are expected. A female passenger, Nichole Williams, was also charged with Co***ne related offenses. Indiana State Police continued the investigation after Taylor’s arrest.

Through the investigation, which involved the Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office, City of Madison Police Department, Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office, the Indiana State Police Drug Enforcement Section, Kentucky State Police Campbellsburg Post and U.S. Marshal’s Office, authorities learned that Taylor was supplying many others with illegal narcotics and led to the numerous arrests on April 15, 2026:

Those arrested are:

Montana Austin, 35, Ghent, KY: Conspiracy to Deal in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) and Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Marcus Benjamin Burgess, 41, Carrollton, KY: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) and Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Shawn Andrew Bushong, 34, Hanover, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine and Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Kayla Lynn Canfield, 32, Hanover, IN: Possession of Methamphetamine (Level 5 Felony), Neglect of a Dependent (Level 5 Felony), Possession of a Controlled Substance (Level 6 Felony), Possession of Ma*****na (Class B Misdemeanor), Possession of Paraphernalia (Class C Misdemeanor)

Elisabeth Coker, 36, Milton, KY: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conpiracy to Commit Unlawful Sale of a Legend Drug (Level 6 Felony) and Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Tristian W. Daniel, 39, Chesterfield, VA: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony)

John Gibbons, 42, Lexington, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in a Narcotic Drug (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Rebecca Elysse Hart, 37, Greensburg, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony) & Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony)

Alanea L. Hawkins, 38, Carrollton, KY: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Shannon W. Hunt, 52, Carrollton, KY: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in a Schedule IV Controlled Substance (Level 6 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Tamara S. Jones, 52, Madison, IN: Maintaining a Common Nuisance (Level 6 Felony)

Alfonzo Delano McPhail, 62, Madison, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in a Schedule IV Controlled Substance (Level 4 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Marshall Murray, 32, Louisville, KY: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Danielle Rache Newton, 34, Hanover, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Travis Lee Reddick, 37, Versailles, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony) & Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony)

Taylor Marie Rowlett, 27, Hanover, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence

Nichole Marie Sheldon, 43, Hanover, IN: Possession of Ma*****na (Class B Misdemeanor) & Visiting a Common Nuisance (Class B Misdemeanor)

Deshawn Standard Jr., 29, Louisville, KY: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Darren Keith Stewart Jr., 31, Madison, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Tammy Stewart, 51, Madison, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Nicholas Michael Tucker, 35, Madison, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in a Schedule IV Controlled Substance (Level 4 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Brogan Lane Vance, 30, North Vernon, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 3 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Valeria Dawn Vanwye, 35, Madison, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 4 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 3 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Ryan Anthony Voris, 31, Madison, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 3 Felony), Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Amber Cheyenne West, 29, Madison, IN: Conspiracy to Deal in Methamphetamine (Level 2 Felony) & Corrupt Business Influence (Level 5 Felony)

Jamie Constance White, 37, Madison, IN: Possession of Ma*****na (Class A Misdemeanor) & Maintaining a Common Nuisance (Level 6 Felony)

Nichole Marie Williams, 33, Madison, IN: Dealing in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony) & Conspiracy to Deal in Co***ne (Level 2 Felony)

Roberto Zavala, 37, Madison, IN: Possession of Ma*****na (Class B Misdemeanor)

04/09/2026

April is Child Abuse Prevention Month, a time to raise awareness, recognize the signs, and take action to protect children.

Child abuse often goes unseen, but not unnoticed. Recognizing the signs and knowing how to report can save a child from continued harm. The Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office encourages you to stay informed and speak up.

“Children are safer when adults are prepared to recognize warning signs and respond appropriately” Said Prosecutor David Sutter.

“It is critical that children can identify safe adults in their life. Whether that be a parent, teacher, or therapist, a trusted individual is someone they can confide in if they experience harm or made to feel uncomfortable. If their concerns are not addressed, they should be encouraged to continue reaching out until someone takes action.”

☎️ If you witness a child being abused or suspect abuse or neglect - report it to the
Indiana Child Abuse and Neglect Hotline (1-800-800-5556) or local enforcement.

04/06/2026

The Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office joins with the community in recognizing April as S*xual Assault Awareness month.

S*xual assault can affect anyone, regardless of age, gender, or background. It is often underreported and many survivors face barriers to coming forward, including fear, stigma, and lack of resources.

“S*xual Assault is a serious and often misunderstood crime that can have lifelong impacts on survivors,” said Prosecutor David Sutter.

“Raising awareness for s*xual assault is essential to helping our community better understand the realities of s*xual violence, importance of consent, and the challenges many survivors face in coming forward. Awareness leads to understanding and understanding strengthens our community.” said Prosecutor Sutter.

If you or someone you know has been affected by s*xual assault, support is available:

For immediate assistance to report an assault call 911 or local law enforcement.

☎️ Safe Passage S*xual Assault Hotline: (812) 932-SAFE (7233)

☎️ The National S*xual Assault Hotline (800-656-HOPE)

🩵 The National S*xual Violence Resource Center - https://www.nsvrc.org

🩵 The Indiana Coalition to End S*xual Assault (ICESA) - https://www.ends*xualassault.org

04/05/2026

The Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office wishes you and your family a happy Easter!

02/12/2026

HARVE HENSLEY SENTENCED TO SIX YEARS IN PRISON FOLLOWING STALKING AND PERJURY CONVICTIONS

Jefferson County, Indiana – On February 9, 2026, Jefferson Superior Court Judge Blaine Goode sentenced Harve Hensley following his stalking and perjury convictions in a bench trial last month. Hensley was sentenced to total of six (6) years all executed at the Indiana Department of Corrections.

“I commend Judge Goode’s issuance of a fully executed sentence as it shows a thorough assessment of the impact of Hensley’s conduct and the facts of the case. It justly considers Hensley’s lack of remorse for disregarding his father’s wishes and the law in addition to refusing to acknowledge the real fear he caused for the victim” said Prosecutor David Sutter

“This sentence provides the victim and their family with much needed peace and security in the years ahead.”

The terror Hensley has brought upon the victim, stems from Hensley’s attempts to establish ownership of property in Deputy, Indiana, to which he has no claim to. Upon his father’s death, Harve was not named as a trustee or beneficiary and hence not allocated property from that trust agreement. The property was later legally sold to the victim in this case. Despite being told by numerous judges and the court of appeals that he has no legal authority or claim to the property; Hensley repeatedly harassed the victim and their family by making unlawful attempts to obtain ownership over the property.

During the sentencing hearing, the Court heard victim impact statements detailing the torment inflicted by Hensley. The victim shared during their statement “Harve’s relentless actions have cast a shadow over what should have been a peaceful sanctuary” adding “the only time we have had any peace is when Harve has been incarcerated”

In imposing the sentence, the Court found multiple aggravating factors, including that the harm suffered by the victim was significant and greater than necessary to prove the offense, that he has a history of criminal behavior, that the crimes were premeditated, that a lesser sentence would depreciate the seriousness of the offenses, and that the Hensley showed a lack of remorse. The Court found no mitigating circumstances.

“If you continue down this course of conduct, you will find yourself in criminal court again.” said Judge Blaine Goode.

Under Indiana law, repeat felony convictions can expose a defendant to substantial sentence enhancements in the future, if the habitual offender status is applicable. The habitual offender enhancement is a sentencing tool that allows the State to seek a significant additional term of incarceration, when a defendant has accumulated a minimum of three (3) prior unrelated felony convictions.

“Our commitment to protecting the people of Jefferson County and holding repeat offenders accountable hasn’t changed. Hensley’s continued pattern of felony convictions is deeply concerning and is moving him closer to meeting the criteria for the habitual offender enhancement. If that threshold is reached in the future, our office will carefully evaluate and pursue that enhancement as appropriate under Indiana law.” said Prosecutor Sutter

02/02/2026

45-YEAR SENTENCE IMPOSED FOR CALCULATED CHILD SEXUAL EXPLOITATION SCHEME

Jefferson County, Indiana — Tyler Perry, 36, of Madison, Indiana was sentenced on February 2, 2026, in the Jefferson County Circuit Court before the Honorable Judge DJ Mote following his conviction of multiple felony offenses involving child s*xual exploitation and the promotion of s*x trafficking of a minor. Perry was sentenced to a total of 45 years, with 35 of those years executed at the Indiana Department of Correction.

Perry was convicted on December 29th 2025, of two (2) counts of Promotion of Child S*xual Trafficking, Level 3 Felonies, one (1) count of Child Exploitation, a Level 5 felony, one (1) count of Child Solicitation, a Level 5 felony, one (1) count Neglect of a Dependent Resulting in Bodily Injury, a Level 5 Felony, and one (1) count Identity Deception, a Level 6 Felony.

“This sentence reflects the seriousness of Perry’s actions, which were calculated, deliberately disguised to evade detection, and involved deception to abuse a child’s trust for his own reprehensible benefit,” said Prosecutor David Sutter.

The investigation, led by the City of Madison Police Department, established that Perry used electronic communication platforms under a false identity to coerce the minor victim into producing s*xually explicit images and videos for payment. The victim initially approached Perry regarding the concerning communications they had received from the accounts. Perry manipulated and forced the victim to continuously engage in the explicit requests. It was later discovered that the online accounts engaging with the victim had actually belonged to Perry, who had been posing as other factitious individuals.

Perry’s criminal activity was uncovered after a disclosure was made to the City of Madison Police Department, prompting an immediate response by MPD Detective Majors Ricky Harris and Kyle Cutshaw. Law enforcement, the Jefferson County Prosecutor’s Office, and the Indiana Department of Child Services worked closely with the Children’s Advocacy Center (CAC) to ensure a trauma-informed, child-centered approach throughout the investigation. This collaboration allowed investigators to gather critical evidence while minimizing further harm to the victim.

Numerous electronic devices were seized belonging to Perry, including cellular phones, computers, and digital storage devices. Forensic examinations of those devices revealed extensive evidence corroborating the victim’s disclosure, including s*xually explicit images of the minor, communications directing the production of those images, and digital efforts to preserve and conceal the material. Investigators additionally, positively identified the online accounts designed to facilitate and disguise the exploitation to have belonged to Perry.

“We teach children to be cautious online and to report any concerns to trusted adults. That is exactly what this child did. Tragically, the person they trusted turned out to be the predator” said Prosecutor David Sutter.

“This was an egregious betrayal of trust, but thanks to the victim’s persistence and courage to seek help, the diligence of the trusted adult who reported the abuse, and the dedicated efforts of law enforcement, we are grateful that Perry has been held accountable.”

Sincere gratitude is extended to the City of Madison Police Department, Detective Major Ricky Harris, Detective Major Kyle Cutshaw, the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office, the Indiana Department of Child Services, the Children’s Advocacy Center of Southeastern Indiana (CAC), Chief Deputy Prosecutor Mark Wynn, and the Dearborn County High Tech Crimes Unit for their coordinated efforts and tireless work throughout this investigation.

Address

315 1/2 East Second Street
Madison, IN
47250

Opening Hours

Monday	8am - 4pm
Tuesday	8am - 4pm
Wednesday	8am - 4pm
Thursday	8am - 4pm
Friday	8am - 4pm

Telephone

+18122658932

Website

https://jeffersoncounty.in.gov/260/Prosecutors-Office

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Jefferson County Prosecutor David Sutter posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Organization

Send a message to Jefferson County Prosecutor David Sutter:

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Organization
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your organization to be the top-listed Government Service in Madison?