11/12/2019
November 11, 2019
Senate Government Operation Committee
Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey
Senate Minority Leader Jim Ananich
Senator Dan Lauwers
Senator Aric Nesbitt
Senator Stephanie Chang
RE: HB 4687 (H-1) and SB 37
Dear Senate Government Operations Committee members,
Michigan United Conservation Clubs is the largest state-specific conservation organization in the nation. With over 200 affiliate clubs and 40,000 members, MUCC advocates positions adopted through a grassroots policy development process open to all members.
Proposal G, a 1996 ballot referendum, was adopted by a 2-1 margin of Michigan voters to give the Natural Resources Commission authority of the manner and method of take for our game species. By supporting Proposal G, Michigan United Conservation Clubs and its members advocated to keep natural resources regulations in the hands of a bi-partisan commission working closely with biologists.
HB 4687 and SB 37 attempt to circumvent Proposal G and the use of sound, scientific research to manage our game species by allowing the use of baiting and feeding for white-tailed deer and other cervids in Michigan. The Michigan Department of Natural Resources has compiled a list of 162 scientific studies related to chronic wasting disease, 42 of which have shown that baiting increases incidence of chronic wasting disease.
Regardless of your position on the baiting and feeding issue, this legislation sets a precedent of wildlife management that is in direct opposition to the will of the citizens of our state. The people of Michigan have voiced their opinion at the ballot box, and it overwhelming supports sound scientific management of our fish and wildlife populations.
Michigan United Conservation Clubs, along with the undersigned conservation organizations, strongly oppose HB 4687 and SB 37 and urge you to oppose this legislation.
Thank you for your consideration.
Organizations opposing HB 4687 and SB 37 include:
Alpena Sportsmen’s Club
Anglers of the Au Sable
Ashley Sportsmen’s Club
Backcountry Hunters and Anglers
Bowfishing Association of Michigan
Cadillac Sportsman’s Club
Chelsea Rod and Gun Club
Coopersville Sportsman’s Club
DeLodder’s Conservation Association
Ducks Unlimited
Hammond Bay Area Anglers Association
HeadWaters Land Conservancy
Huron Valley Conservation Association
Kalamazoo Rod and Gun Club
Lake St. Clair Walleye Association
Livingston County Wildlife and Conservation Club
Macatawa Bay Waterfowl Association
Michigan Bass Federation
Michigan Bear Hunters Association
Michigan Bow Hunters Association
Michigan Environmental Council
Michigan Hunting Dog Federation
Michigan Quality Deer Management Association
Michigan State Chapter of the National Wild Turkey Federation
Michigan State Fox Hunters Association
Michigan State United Coonhunters Association
Michigan Steelhead and Salmon Fishermen’s Association
Michigan Trout Unlimited
Mid-Forest Lodge
Mid-Michigan Branch of Quality Deer Management Association
Montmorency County Conservation Club
National Wildlife Federation
Northwest Michigan Quality Deer Management Association
Oceana Archers, Inc.
Presque Isle Sportsmen’s Club
Richmond Sportsman’s Club
Straits Area Sportsmen’s Club
Tomahawk Archers
Tri-County Sportsmen’s League
Upper Black River Council
Upper Peninsula Bear Hunters Association
West Shore Branch of Quality Deer Management Association
Western Michigan Brittany Club