09/03/2026
Continuing with the theories behind the Jellico Dynamite Explosion of Friday, September 21, 1906: to reiterate, months of investigation by experts, lawyers, railroads, and federal courts never came to a conclusion on the exact cause of the explosion. Also, as a point, the Southern Railway and L&N Railroad did everything they could legally to absolve themselves of any court determined blame in the disaster. The causation of the event eluded those who lived through the actual blast. Looking back today, from 120 years on, there is no way to go back and prove or disprove any of the multiple theories. Yesterday, we looked at the “simple” theory that Walter Rogers shot into a boxcar of dynamite with a .22 rifle and set off the blast. Surely sounds plausible! But hold on! Other witnesses told a different narrative entirely. Let’s look at the “kicking” of a train-car-load of pig iron into the dynamite car scenario.
First off, we know from Yerkes (Southern conductor) testimony, that his train brought the load of dynamite into the yard on September 20th hitched to a load of pig iron. Some said the cars were separated overnight with a distance of 70 feet between them.
Secondly, by railroad rules, pig iron and lumber cars must not be next to dynamite cars. “Rule #28: Provides that explosives must not be taken on passenger trains. Stationmasters and yardmasters must know of presence of explosives and have them placed in the yard to prevent explosion. Also, explosives must not be near cars of lumber or pig iron as they may cause explosion. In yards the cars containing explosives must be placed so they can not get struck or catch fire.” Per Knoxville News Sentinel June 13, 1907 in federal court. “The rules were in effect before the explosion at Jellico.”
In one day of court testimony, 9 witnesses stated they saw the Southern switch engine, #277, kick a load of pig iron forcefully into the boxcar of dynamite. "Kicking cars" means pushing one or more railcars with a locomotive, uncoupling them while they are still moving, and letting them roll freely into a different track under their own momentum.
The dynamics of the day were complex with several engines operating in the yard. Testimonies varied at what engine was where, what engine was doing what, if there even was a Southern switch engine in the yard. Indeed, there developed an elusiveness surrounding the Southern switch engine which was never fully solved. At any rate, at the exact instant the load of pig iron was supposedly witnessed being “kicked” against the dynamite car for hitching, Walter Rogers and his friends were nearby shooting the .22 rifle. Nearly simultaneously, as the cars collided, and perhaps a shot was being fired, a massively powerful explosion rocked Jellico bringing tremendous destruction upon the town.
Did the sudden impact of the two cars cracking together trigger the explosion? Did the cars merely hit at the exact instant Walter Rogers may have sent a bullet into the boxcar of dynamite? Did both occurrences, by an uncanny act of precise timing, set off the blast? A hard coupling shock and a bullet in the dynamite at the exact same time? Again, I don’t think anyone can ever determine for sure. The event is simply a “mystery of history”.