03/27/2013
Just history repeating itself again.
As Republican statists have been pointing out all over the media today, gay Americans have the same marital rights as straight Americans: they can marry someone of the opposite s*x.
Obviously, that would be the same as if we banned all religions except the Church of the Spaghetti Monster, but gave all people the same right to practice that one religion. That's hardly real freedom of religion.
In the past, gay americans had one option: heteros*xual marriage. Then human innovation brought us the idea of gay marriage, and that gave them more options. And as usual, the government has worked hard to block that innovation.
The same often happens wherever the government meddles. If you happen to learn best in a school with 2000 students with a curriculum designed by the county, then the government will support you. In fact, it will even steal money from your neighbors to pay your tuition. If you would do better in a private or religious school, that's okay too, but you have to pay your own tuition. If, however, you would do better learning from a tutor, or from one of the hundreds of learning centers around the country, that is quite possibly illegal in your state (http://votevohra.com/index.php/rethinking-vouchers-and-mandatory-schooling-laws/). Without government blockades, parents could use more of the educational options that there are right now, and there would be more ability for innovators to come up with new options.
The same applies to marriage. Legalizing gay marriage is like legalizing one specific type of private school. It just adds one more protected group, but doesn't free up innovation.
Human relations are complex and individual. No two relationships are exactly the same (even two heteros*xual monogamist ones). But the great thing about the human mind is that it can innovate, and find ways to make things work. In the past, innovations included divorce, and even consent (in noble families in various cultures, the bride and groom had no real choice in whom they married.) Present innovations include gay marriages, open marriages, and poly marriages. What will the future hold? Short term marriages, plural marriages, or something else that we haven't even dreamed of yet? Will human relationships benefit from the same innovation that turned the ENIAC into the i-Phone? Will we have the courage and wisdom to allow human innovation to make ourselves and our fellow people happier? Or will we continue to allow government meddlers to block innovation and happiness?
Let's once and for all completely get the government out of marriage - and education, entertainment, currency, food, and everywhere else it blockades innovation and holds back human genius. We can do better without its interference.