06/23/2026
~JURY RETURNS GUILTY VERDICTS IN LESS THAN 15 MINUTES; DEFENDANT SENTENCED TO 3 YEARS IN IDOC~
DANVILLE, IN – Following a jury trial this week, a Hendricks County jury found Matthew Mensch GUILTY on all counts in less than fifteen minutes of deliberation.
The convictions stem from a series of threats, intimidation, stalking behavior, and the distribution of an intimate image directed at his former girlfriend and her family.
Evidence presented at trial showed that after the relationship ended, Mensch repeatedly threatened his ex girlfriend and her family through text messages and voicemail recordings. In one voicemail, Mensch threatened to come to the family’s home and kill them if victims did not contact him. Additional text messages contained threats directed toward the victim, her daughter, and her daughter’s fiancé.
On October 31, 2023, Mensch drove to the family’s North Salem residence where he aggressively pounded on doors, screamed profanities, and attempted to force contact with the victims while they were inside with a small child. Security camera footage captured Mensch at the residence and showed him removing and damaging security cameras from the property.
The jury found Mensch guilty of three counts: two counts of Intimidation as level 6 felony, Distribution of an Intimate Image as an A misdemeanor.
Following the verdict, the Court immediately proceeded to sentencing and ordered Mensch to serve three years incarcerated in the Indiana Department of Correction.
“Hendricks County families should never have to live in fear because someone refuses to accept that a relationship has ended,” said Loren Delp Hendricks County Prosecutor. “Threats of violence, intimidation, stalking behavior, and attempts to terrorize victims will be treated seriously. This swift verdict sends a clear message that our community will stand with victims and hold offenders accountable.”
Prosecutor Delp also recognized Deputy Prosecutor Ashley Snoke, who served as first chair during the trial.
This case marked Ms. Snoke’s first jury trial as lead counsel. Her preparation, professionalism, and courtroom advocacy helped secure guilty verdicts on every count charged.
“The first jury trial is a milestone in every prosecutor’s career,” Delp said. “Ashley did an outstanding job presenting the evidence, advocating for the victims, and seeking justice. We are proud of her accomplishment and look forward to her continued service protecting Hendricks County families.”
The Hendricks County Prosecutor’s Office thanks Deputy Prosecutor Ashley Snoke, Officer Corey Shaffer, the North Salem Police Department, and all law enforcement personnel involved in the investigation and prosecution of this case.