12/04/2025
It's Official — Carmel-by-the-Sea Council Is a National Embarrassment: Votes to Ban Pickleball Despite Overwhelming Community Opposition and Make It a Crime Punishable by $1,000 Fine!
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA, CA — December 3, 2025
In a stunning display of government overreach that has sparked outrage among residents, the Carmel City Council voted unanimously last night to ban pickleball at Forest Hill Park and make it a misdemeanor offense punishable by fines up to $1,000. The decision disregarded overwhelming public support and a compromise previously approved by the City's Beach and Parks Commission, effectively criminalizing a harmless, community-building sport enjoyed by seniors, families, and tourists for over 13 years.
The chamber was packed to capacity with one of the largest turnouts in recent memory. After nearly an hour of ceremonial proceedings, when Mayor Dale Byrne attempted to take a dinner break before hearing the item, the audience erupted in loud boos, forcing him to retreat and take only a brief five-minute pause instead.
The Mayor also limited public comment to one minute instead of the traditional three minutes, drawing further outrage from attendees.
During public comment, the divide was stark: roughly 90% of speakers supported pickleball while only about 10% opposed it. Yet the Council voted 100% in favor of the ban. Residents say the decision was driven by outsiders, political favoritism, and a tiny group of neighbors—not the community's actual needs.
Southern California transplant Mayor Dale Byrne has lived in Carmel only since 2017 and was elected in a three-way race winning by just 118 votes in November 2024. He positioned himself as a cultural authority over lifelong residents, many of whom noted this was not an issue before Byrne became Mayor. Attendees observed it seemed possible Byrne was siding with a personal friend—one of the handful of neighbors demanding the ban.
A fully vetted compromise unanimously approved by the Beach and Parks Commission had balanced hours, noise mitigation, and shared use, but Mayor Byrne rejected it outright.
"This wasn't a process — it was a setup," said Cara Franklin, organizer of the Pickleball Is Not a Crime Committee and a regular Forest Hill Park player. "Five complaining neighbors got exactly what they wanted, and the community was ignored."
Residents emphasized that surrounding cities including Monterey, Pacific Grove, Seaside, and Marina have all embraced pickleball with reasonable compromises, making Carmel the only city on the Peninsula to ban the sport outright. The City's own website had promoted the courts as pickleball courts, and the sport had been played peacefully for over 13 years.
It was also learned that local community leaders helped fix the tennis-pickleball courts 13 years ago and that it has been the senior pickleball players who have kept the courts maintained ever since.
The ordinance makes pickleball a misdemeanor with fines up to $1,000. Criminalizing a healthy, community-building activity—played by seniors, families, and tourists—is government extremism. No reasonable city uses police power to stop exercise. The City Council is considering using law enforcement to address pickleball "violations" in a low-crime town where police resources should not be wasted policing playgrounds. The ban is driven by five neighbors, not the community—a fact confirmed by the Mayor in an interview with KSBW TV. A tiny minority living next to the park is pushing the ban.
Public spaces belong to everyone, not just adjacent homeowners. Policy should reflect community needs, not the loudest complainers. If you live near a park, you should expect people, kids, movement, and sound. Parks are not meant to be silent courtyards curated for a few. Banning recreation undermines Carmel's identity as an active, welcoming coastal community.
The decision has already generated national mockery with headlines describing it as "wealthy California town bans pickleball over noise" and "peak rich-people politics." National headlines and viral meeting footage have made Carmel a punchline on social media. Residents warn the ban damages Carmel's image, sends the wrong message to visitors who are the town's economic lifeline, and reinforces perceptions that newcomers run the town.
"This makes Carmel a national embarrassment," said Brandon Michael Gesicki, a public affairs strategist and Carmel area resident. "It tells visitors we're hostile to recreation, families, and fun." The Council has damaged Carmel's reputation as a desired international place to visit.
Serious questions have been raised about the fairness of the process. The City held a special meeting for Forest Hill Park in September that pickleball players were never notified about. The Mayor made statements that allegedly misrepresented the process and contradicted the public record. Public input was minimized or dismissed.
"This looks like a predetermined outcome designed to give a few friends exactly what they demanded," Gesicki said.
Other cities solved pickleball noise with adjusted hours, modest sound barriers, court resurfacing or relocation, and better scheduling. Carmel skipped every reasonable solution and went straight to a ban. Meanwhile, Carmel faces urgent issues including housing shortages, worker gaps, aging infrastructure, library modernization needs, business corridor decline, and tourism resiliency problems. While the Council debates quiet balls and decibel tests, major development projects sit stalled, infrastructure needs remain unmet, housing pressures continue, business corridors need revitalization, and tourism management requires urgent planning.
"Instead of solving a single real problem, the Council spent months eliminating a harmless sport enjoyed by kids, seniors, and families. It's weak leadership — and it hurts Carmel," Gesicki said. Government should facilitate recreation, not eliminate it. When City Hall starts banning normal activities instead of managing them, it has lost perspective.
If pickleball is banned because it's "too loud," what's next? Barking dogs? Kids playing tag? Basketball? Banning one sport sets a precedent for banning others. How much in taxpayer dollars was spent on staff time, legal reviews, and hearings for this ban?
About Pickleball: Pickleball is the fastest-growing sport in the U.S., with nearly 20 million players in 2024 and 45.8% year-over-year growth from 2023. The sport's accessibility, ease of learning, and social nature have driven participation, with over 19% of U.S. adults having played in the last 12 months. There are now over 68,000 courts nationwide, with the number expanding rapidly.
CONTACT:
Brandon Michael Gesicki
[email protected]
Pickleball Is Not a Crime Committee
Cara Franklin, Organizer
Send a message to learn more