07/10/2019
I (Dr. Howell) got to spend two hours talking Soylent Green, the 1973 dystopian thriller (link to trailer below), with a class of honors students recently. I knew it was an environmental film, but I had never seen it. In the famous death scene, Charleton Heston tells everyone that what they thought about Soylent Green, that it was a plankton based snack, is no longer true. In fact, it is MADE OUT OF PEOPLE that this society processes at "Waste Disposal Plants". Have you ever seen the film? It brings up some thoughtful questions about how we affect the environment and how the environment affects us:
(1) If there comes a time where, locally or globally, there are more people than our environment can reasonably provide for, what should we do?
(2) Will we value people less just because there are many of them, and we together exert a high environmental cost?
(3) If we do great damage to the environment in such a way as to limit the viability of survival and quality of life for those that come after us, have we done injustice to our descendants?
(4) What role is there for mercy and human dignitity if you live in a time of great scarcity?
These questions go beyond a science and engineering understanding of the environment. In engineering, we cannot by ourselves, answer all of these questions. Part of our responsibility in understanding the limits of enviornmental capcity and the consequences of engineering decisions on the environment is to get people talking about what I would say is an underlying question behind nearly all environmental problems, "What is the purpose and value of people, and what does that purpose/value dictate concerning how we should interact with our environment?"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_jGOKYHxaQ