09/01/2026
The Twelfth Court of Appeals has upheld the murder conviction and life sentence of Chaz Taelor White, who was convicted by a Henderson County jury last October in the 2023 killing of Alexis Garoutte.
White appealed his conviction, arguing that the evidence was insufficient to prove he had the intent required for a murder conviction.
The Court of Appeals rejected that argument, concluding that the jury was justified in finding beyond a reasonable doubt that White intentionally and knowingly killed Garoutte. The court found the evidence sufficient to support the jury’s guilty verdict.
White, 35, was convicted following a week-long trial in 392nd District Court. Judge Scott McKee sentenced him to life in prison Oct. 27.
The case stemmed from the April 21, 2023, shooting of Garoutte on Sailfish Drive in Mabank. Henderson County Sheriff’s Office deputies found Garoutte in the passenger seat of a Dodge Ram and attempted lifesaving measures, but she died at the scene.
During the trial, White admitted that he fired a Saiga AK-47 toward the truck. Prosecutors presented evidence that White believed he was shooting at another person at the scene, gave the firearm to his wife to dispose of after the shooting and later told a friend he thought he had “caught a murder charge.”
Assistant District Attorney Jessica Bargmann and First Assistant District Attorney Daniel Cox prosecuted the trial. Bargmann, Cox and Assistant District Attorney Beth Neu were involved in defending the conviction on appeal.