14/06/2020
Remembering Shujaat
By Iftikhar Gilani
Shujaat Bukhari: Man, with ideas and ideals:
When cross-LoC passenger bus service connecting Srinagar and Muzaffarabad was being flagged-off by then Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on April 7, 2005, Shujaat Bukhari in his indomitable style rang up and recalled one of our conversation in New Delhi back in 1994.
Many people across the world from Ambassador McDonald to a host of think-tanks, peaceniks, backchannel and track II actors were claiming credit for floating the idea of the bus service and cross-LoC connectivity, which was perhaps the first and so far the only confidence-building measure (CBM) between India and Pakistan involving people of Jammu and Kashmir. Even though the issue of Jammu and Kashmir had been center of the dispute between the two countries, but all the CBMs enacted over the past 70 years be that security or trade issues, excluded the region.
Way back in 1994, he recalled our private conversation about the idea. In 1978 assembly elections, the National Conference (NC) under Sheikh Mohammad Abdullah had made it an election plank in North Kashmir. Sheikh’s deputy Mirza Mohammad Afzal Beg in various public gatherings after finishing his speech was symbolically showing a green handkerchief and rock salt to people to press the point that once back to power, they will reopen historical and traditional linkages to Kashmir. The region which was once a connecting link had been pushed to the periphery by the events that overtook the region in the 20th century. The animosity between India and Pakistan further vitiated it.
The bespectacled man with a warm smile and generous manners, Shujaat took up the idea and discussed with the then political counselor at the US Embassy in Delhi. Just a day later, he told me that Americans have shown an interest in the idea and the lady counselor Elizabeth (I remember only her first name) wanted him to meet Frank G. Wisner, who had taken over as the Ambassador almost a year later after Thomas R. Pickering had completed his tenure. He wanted me to accompany him to press this point further and to explain it in a historical perspective.
In 2015, Shujaat was only recalling that unlike others we had not put the proposal in any written format. The man who tried all his career to build bridges, restore peace with dignity, and find ways to move towards resolution was the author and proponent of this biggest CBM.
Whenever I was in Srinagar he would lend me his spare mobile phone. Delhi phones were not working in Kashmir and it was not the place to feel cut off and out of contact.
A voice of reason and hope and a brilliant reporter, who had contacts all around in both India and Pakistan had never stopped looking on the future for Kashmir with optimism.
He tried hard to bridge the gaps, and always dreamt of keeping hopes alive by encouraging Srinagar-Delhi-Islamabad dialogue. At all track II or private meetings, I remember, he would always valiantly put forward Kashmir centric point, which would at times irritate many in Delhi. He was critical of the establishment that would always loathe people who talk with the sense of independence and impartiality that was so refreshing for all dealing with Kashmir.
Who gained from this death? It is a question haunting all of us. Soon after his departure, the door that Shujaat Bukhari tried so hard to keep open for the sake of the future he believed in was slammed shut.
Bukhari’s murder is a tragedy not only for his family but for all of us in Kashmir and outside. It is also a tragedy for press freedom and peacebuilding. Without a political solution with people at the center, conflict in the region will inevitably continue, and on-the-ground reporting will be compromised. In his last column, Shujaat wrote: “Local support to militancy has increased. Unless a political approach is adopted by the government, violence will continue to make headlines. And with provocations from the government in Delhi which are further supplemented by TV channels, there is hardly any chance and hope to see a change.”
Rest in peace, my friend. It is not easy to live a life without you. Still at times, when I get stuck on some issue, I tend to dial his number, which I have still stored in my phone. I
do not dare to delete it.