15/06/2026
Bannockburn World Cup Round #1
Bernard, Abbot of Arbroath (SCO) vs Walter Fitz Gilbert (SCO)
Bernard, Abbot of Arbroath, was one of the key administrative figures in Scotland for almost all of Robert I's reign. He was serving as Abbot of Kilwinning in Ayrshire (Bruce's 'backyard', so to speak) in 1296 but was probably forced out by English pressure following the outbreak of the war. He enjoyed a remarkable resurgence under Bruce, who likely sponsored his election as Abbot of Arbroath and also appointed him as his chancellor. This made Bernard responsible for overseeing the production of official royal documentation and gave him a prominent position on the king's council. He may have been present at Bannockburn but is unlikely to have done any fighting, instead providing spiritual support to Bruce and his army and perhaps even continuing to serve an administrative function amid the preparations for the battle. Bernard also appears to have composed a verse chronicle celebrating King Robert's life, fragments of which survive in a fifteenth-century chronicle called the Scotichronicon. The fragmentary nature of the surviving evidence makes it difficult to say much for certain about it, but it was probably compiled between March 1324 and February 1327, a time of truce between Scotland and England when Scottish confidence was high. The tone seems to have been fairly triumphal, glorifying Bruce's cunning tactics and delighting in the birth of the king's son David. It also includes the earliest surviving version of the speech Bruce supposedly gave to his troops ahead of the fighting at Bannockburn. While it is unlikely Bruce gave any such address, it is at least likely what Bruce *wanted* people to think he said, since the document was likely commissioned by him for recitation at his court. As such, it provides valuable insight into Bruce's understanding of his own achievement in 1314. Bernard likely also had considerable influence over the contents of the famous Declaration of Arbroath in 1320 and towards the end of his life he also served as Bishop of the Isles, an appointment that may represent a reward of sorts from King Robert for Bernard's years of faithful service.
Walter Fitz Gilbert was not present at Bannockburn, but was serving the English as captain of Bothwell Castle (pictured, right) in Lanarkshire at the time of the battle. In the 1290s he appears to have been associated with the Stewarts, Bruce's great allies, so why exactly he was not supporting Bruce is unclear. However, following the English defeat at Bannockburn, a company of Englishmen led by Humphrey de Bohun, earl of Hereford, fled from the battlefield to Bothwell, being welcomed in by Walter and his men. Whatever his previous feelings towards Bruce, when Walter learned what had happened in the recent battle, he realised that now was not a good time to be a Scot in English employ. He thus took Humphrey and co. prisoner and wrote to King Robert, who at that time was overseeing the demolition of Stirling Castle, and offered to surrender Bothwell and all of his prisoners to the Scottish king in return for being allowed to switch sides! Bruce welcomed Walter with open arms, since Humphrey was a sufficiently prestigious prisoner to be exchanged for Bruce's wife Elizabeth, daughter from his first marriage Marjory, sister Christina, and Robert Wishart, Bishop of Glasgow, all of whom had been prisoners in England since 1306. In the years that followed, Walter was rewarded for his timely change of allegiance with grants of the baronies of Machan and Cadzow in Lanarkshire and Kinneil in West Lothian. By the 1380s, his grandson David had adopted the surname 'Hamilton' (from another of their Lanarkshire baronies) and the modern dukes of Hamilton are his descendants.
Hit Like to vote for Bernard, hit Heart to vote for Walter!