19/05/2026
*** BOOK GROUP REPORT ***
I was somewhat out in the cold with this month's choice, 'Cold Comfort Farm' by Stella Gibbons. It was my second attempt to read it and both attempts ended around page 60. Part of me wishes I'd buckled down and put the effort in, as several of our members found it a book that was hard to start with but you had to relax into its preposterousness.
Published in 1932 it parodies the pretentious literary language of the likes of Mary Webb, DH Lawrence and Thomas Hardy, and specifically their "loam and lovechild" and doom-laden accounts of rural life. Our group members found within it elements of all manner of such authors, and the gothic novels of the time.
The descriptions of the creepy farmhouse and its inhabitants work wonderfully. Humour underlies everything from the naming of the cows (Pointless, Aimless et al), the hellfire preacher at the Church of the Quivering Brethren ("Ye're all damned!") Amos Starkadder, and Adam Lambsbreath the 90-year-old farm-hand with his "liddle mop". There was a lightbulb moment for many as they read of Aunt Ada's encounter with "something nasty in the woodshed".
The book was massively popular, yet some voices expressed disapproval. Virginia Woolf was one, declaring it lacked literary merit and irritated by its mockery of the Bloomsbury set. For its time, it was quite raunchy... and written by a woman! It must have got up the aristocratic Woolf nose even more in 1933, as it won the Femina Vie Heureuse Prize - a prestigious French award for outstanding works by English authors. In 1928, Virginia Woolf had won it for 'To the Lighthouse' :-)
The blurb on the back of 'Cold Comfort Farm' describes it as "the most hilarious book ever written". Spoiler... it's not. All those who read it thought it was funny; it raised smiles in all but a laugh-out-loud in only a couple. I've rarely seen the book group so bonded over a book. They were bouncing quotes and funny moments back and forth across the circle of chairs like a room of Gen Xers after their first encounter with 'The Colour of Magic', Terry Pratchett's first Discworld novel.
Rosemary H, who chose 'Cold Comfort Farm' for us, tried to give it three thumbs up as revisiting it was such an unexpected pleasure for her - but I can only allow her the one. So, the book gained 10 thumbs up, although a couple of those were lukewarm in that they wouldn't recommend it but were glad they'd read it; it was "interesting" and I stood alone as totally not getting the humour -or indeed the point of it. C'est la vie.
Next month we'll meet on the 16th to discuss the contemporary 2024 romance novel 'You Are Here' by David Nicholls. All welcome, and no need to buy the book as we have enough loan copies for everyone.
Image from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=76883898