06/12/2022
Island media can seem like it doesn't ask the hard questions at times, or ignores tough issues, but there are exceptions, and here is a glimpse at one's frustrations trying to do his job:
From CBC PEI journalist Kerry Campbell
Friday, June 10th, 2022
via Twitter
It's now been 590 days since I filed an access request for the Brendel Farms report. It's been 1,345 days since I asked for information on a death at Sleepy Hollow that, in other provinces, would have been made public as a matter of routine disclosure.
"I think this is the most open and transparent government in the history of Prince Edward Island. I’m very proud (Indistinct)," Premier Dennis King said in the PEI Legislature on May 3, according to Hansard.'
Under the previous govt I got used to the province not asking me to pay for most access requests. Those were the good times. Now invoices in the hundreds of dollars are routine, and I don't feel like departments are engaging with me in good faith as I try to whittle those down.
A functional access-to-information system is a critical component of a healthy democracy. When it takes four years (and counting) just to find out whether a person who died in custody received appropriate medical care, that's a problem.
'm also still waiting on these records I applied for in early 2020. These are forms corporations submit to IRAC on land ownership. Technically, their land holdings are public information, available through PEI's land titles office.
My frustration today is over a request for records on
's ambulance system. The bill came back at $330. I asked for a breakdown, then told the province we could eliminate the item responsible for 6 of 14 hours of searching in response to this request. The bill is still $330.
That request was spurred on by the story of George Kinch, as told by his daughter, who died of a heart attack earlier this year. I don't know that he could have been saved, but it took the ambulance more than an hour to arrive.
Hey everyone, thanks for being there for me. Sometimes a journalist just has to vent, you know? ....
---Kerry Campbell,
June 10th, 2022
----------
"Democracy dies in darkness" is the slogan on the masthead of The Washington Post, a phrase based on a quote from a United States judge several decades ago, and it fits here, too. We probably need to be more vocal about reminding the provincial government that they are *not* living up to their assertion of transparency (this goes for all levels of government, too).
Kudos to Kerry, and Stu Neatby at The Guardian, and Rachel Collier and publisher Paul MacNeill at The Graphic publications, and citizens like Martin Ruben for their perseverance.
Yours truly,
Chris Ortenburger,
Citizens' Alliance of P.E.I.