12/06/2021
Behind the Newtown Creek Wastewater Resource Recovery Facility are four flares where “excess” methane generated from the digester eggs is burned off- putting CO2 and other greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere. People often ask us what’s happening here, because the story isn’t clear...
In 2012, NYC Water New York City Department of Sanitation Waste Management National Grid began a project to add food waste to the digester eggs and generate larger amounts of methane, adding the upcycled gas into National Grid’s local supply (displacing fracked gas)*. As designed, the project aims to process up to 250 tons per day of food waste, generating enough gas for 5,200 customers.
The original completion date for the project was January 2016. Then it was February 2020. Then it was August 2021. Now it is March 2022**. To date, none of the gas generated by the eggs is being fed into the system, or used by New Yorkers. In fact; it’s being burned into the atmosphere. Every day. For the last 6 years.
The flaring of viable heating and cooking gas is a hugely wasteful problem, and definitely not worthy of accolades. National Grid continues to champion the project as an example of their commitment to renewable energy without actually supplying us the energy. This project is 6 years behind schedule and $33 million over budget***. This false achievement was even championed during this past year’s rate case hearings with the Public Service Commission, where the PSC sided with National Grid’s commitment to clean energy (while hypocritically also raising rates to pay for new fossil fuel infrastructure).
We stand with local allies in fighting against new fossil fuel infrastructure. We support new renewable energy infrastructure. But we need to all acknowledge the realities of a project that is seriously behind schedule and adding to local climate emissions as a result.
*According to figures provided by National Grid, the system processed approximately 120,000 tons of food scraps from June 2016 to December 2020 - and continues to receive between 50 to 200 tons per day. This is extra organic material added to the existing sewage sludge within the eggs, all being burned off and creating extra Greenhouse Gas emissions.
** With the exception of the most recent, all of these milestone dates have been stated in public meetings and in public documents, assuaging the community of the project’s viability.
*** The original 2012 budget was $14.6 million; actual expenses as of February 2021 were $47.8 million.
Sane Energy Project No North Brooklyn Pipeline Greenpointers Stephen Levin Lincoln Restler Assemblymember Emily Gallagher