08/10/2026
NEVER AGAIN WILL THE POLICE BATON PROTESTERS OFF THE STREET
By Brian Feeney
The past fortnight has been a watershed which has graphically demonstrated the illegitimacy of this place
THE Court of Appeal heard the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition case on Monday, exactly 58 years to the day since the RUC batoned peaceful civil rights demonstrators off Duke Street in Derry.
That wouldn’t have struck a chord with many unionists, but as the jester says in Shakespeare’s As You Like It, “thereby hangs a tale”.
Here’s the thing. Regardless of court verdicts, Parades Commission determinations, or what have you, it’s never going to happen again.
The PSNI may be 70% Protestant but unionists don’t any longer own the police. They will not do their bidding.
The DUP MP Carla Lockhart (and she’s not the only one) has demanded that the “police do their job”, by which she obviously means tear into the vast crowd on Garvaghy Road with batons and water cannon.
Has she no idea that would be the end of the PSNI as an acceptable police service?
Does she care, or does she not realise the sea change that has taken place in the north?
Drumcree and Orange marches and the police are not in the same place as they were 30 years ago.
The past fortnight has graphically demonstrated the illegitimacy of this place.
As is often the case, those who have exposed its illegitimacy are the very people who should be working to pretend their “wee country” is legitimate and a viable entity.
We have a proconsul from Britain who is so out of his depth as to be utterly useless, unable to take the decision to ban the parade, which he has the power to do. He doesn’t have to wait for the chief constable to advise him disorder is out of control.
We have an Assembly which is equally useless and has no power to deal with parades. It’s exposed as the glorified county council it is.
Last Tuesday, after a slanging match which lasted two days, they packed it in because, guess what, they had no other business to transact.
So the north’s elected representatives are spectators and commentators at the events on the streets and the proconsul, police and courts have no control over them. That’s a pretty comprehensive illegitimacy, isn’t it?
And here’s the kicker. Nothing will happen to any of the protesters on Garvaghy Road, despite poor Gavin Robinson’s repeated, futile, forlorn appeals for the “extensive PSNI investigation” to bear fruit.
The past 10 days have constituted a watershed, a watershed which showed that the north can’t be run without the consent of its majority population – the nationalists. A bit of a turnaround, eh?
The contrast between the predominantly young, ebullient crowds on Garvaghy Road – with visiting bands like The Mary Wallopers, Beoga, Lankum, spontaneous cèilidhean sessions – and the sparse gathering of Orange supporters could not have been more stark.
On Saturday afternoon it’s reckoned up to 15,000 travelled from all over Ireland to stand on Garvaghy Road in a carnival atmosphere.
Sunday’s gathering on the Orange side looked like a metaphor for the state of unionism. A few hundred maybe, heads bowed in the twilight for a prayer service, then a band blattering drums.
Some of the Orangemen wearing bowler hats, the very symbol of the past.
Do you think that there’s any unionist leader capable of telling them that it’s over, that they can’t have what they want, that they’ve exposed the terminal weakness of unionism, that most unionists actually don’t support marching through nationalist districts?
Polls show over 70% of unionists either disagree or disagree strongly with marching where they’re not wanted.
Do you think the letter initiated by east Belfast Baptist pastor Rev Karen Sethuraman and signed by over 1,000 “concerned individuals from a Protestant background” will have any effect, and if not, why not?
Sunday’s gathering on the Orange side looked like a metaphor for the state of unionism. A few hundred maybe, heads bowed in the twilight for a prayer service, then a band blattering drums.
Some of the Orangemen wearing bowler hats, the very symbol of the past.
Those signatures were amassed in two days, itself evidence of the strong unionist opposition to what the Portadown Orangemen have provoked.
Can no one pe*****te the tiny particle of political brain those guys at Drumcree possess? Can no one convince them of the damage they’re doing to unionism and its project?
As my colleague Alex Kane wrote last week, the Assembly will just be unworkable now, a forum of ya boo hiss because it’s impossible to see how, if no political relations have developed over 25 years, they can develop now.
You’d think it would be in unionist parties’ interest to promote a successful regional assembly, but they seem to be competing with each other to make the north unworkable.
In the last 10 days unionists of all shades have successfully proved the republican case that partition is the problem and that the north is a failed political entity.
The past fortnight has graphically demonstrated the illegitimacy of this place